5 Red Flags Hiring Managers should pay attention to Harte

Choosing the right candidate for the job is a skill that can significantly impact a company's success. I have been a recruitment consultant for over a decade and there are five warning signs during interviews that I think hiring managers should always be wary of.

Inability to Acknowledge Weaknesses and Failure


During interviews candidates will obviously wish to highlight their successes, but if they are unable to admit to any past failures this can be a telling red flag. Acknowledging and learning from mistakes is crucial for personal and professional growth. Hiring managers should view a candidate's ability to discuss failures as an opportunity to gauge their humility and capacity for self-improvement.


Blaming Others


Candidates who consistently blame others for any issues or setbacks may lack accountability and a willingness to learn from their experiences. A blame culture can create a feeling of negativity within a workplace, which then inhibits your team members’ potential to contribute positively to a team and grow professionally.


Badmouthing a Past Employer


While everyone has a reason for quitting their last job, openly criticising a past employer during an interview can be a red flag. Trash-talking reflects negatively on the candidate's attitude and professionalism, potentially signaling a focus on their dissatisfaction with their previous role rather than enthusiasm for the prospective role.

A Lack of Knowledge About Your Company


In an age when information is so easily accessible, candidates who haven’t taken time to research your company before an interview are, in my opinion, demonstrating a lack of initiative. Thorough research demonstrates that a candidate is genuinely interested and committed to the potential role, whereas a lack thereof might suggest a disinterest in both your company and the potential role.

Poor Communication


The way in which a candidate communicates and behaves towards you can tell you a lot about them. If a candidate is slow to respond or fails to respond to calls and emails it can be a red flag. It also suggests that maybe the opportunity that you are offering is not their top priority. On interview day do they struggle to find you due to disorganisation? I am not suggesting you hold a genuine hiccup against them but if communication and behaviour is consistently poor then it would be a big red flag for me. 


In the ever-evolving landscape of recruitment, mastering the art of identifying genuine red flags leads to more informed and successful hiring decisions. I have been helping hiring managers to find their ideal candidates for over a decade now. If you would like to know more about how I can help you please give me a call.


Current Roles 

By Elliot Landy April 30, 2025
How many times have you felt like you’re surrounded by idiots? There might be a very good reason for this (unless they are certified idiots, then you’re screwed!). 🥴 At Harte, we frequently refer to Persona Profiling, which uses four colours (red, blue, yellow and green) to identify individual traits so we can develop a better understanding of ourselves and others. From a recruitment point of view, this helps to define a job seeker’s characteristics and assess whether they’d be suited to a role or fit in with a business’s culture. Someone who is a ‘fiery red’ for example, will be results-orientated, strong-willed, and driven to achieve, whereas a ‘cool blue’ personality will have a more conventional energy that thrives on analysis and asking questions before making a move. Knowing this sort of information makes finding the right ‘fit’ for a company a whole lot easier because we have a clear idea of the traits and behaviours that are aligned with the role. It also gives us an indication of when we need to take a step back and slow things down in interviews to really get to know the job-seeker properly. If you’re keen to find out more about the four personality types, have a read of (or listen to) this book: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Surrounded-Idiots-Behavior-Effectively-Communicate/dp/1250179947 Do you know what energy colour you lead by?
By Elliot Landy April 29, 2025
Basic salary: Up to £63,000, £5,100 car allowance, so total up to £68,100 per annum, plus a 5% annual discretionary bonus. Location: Leeds
By Elliot Landy April 29, 2025
Basic salary: Up to £35k (D.O.E) with bonus on top (min £2k), OTE £37k Location: Manchester
More Roles