Recruitment Red Flags: How to Spot a Potential Flop Before It’s Too Late!

Recruitment can feel like a treasure hunt, but sometimes you end up with fool’s gold. Let’s uncover the red flags that signal a potential flop, so you can avoid costly mistakes and find the gems you’re looking for.

Résumé Red Flags


Job-Hopping: While career changes are normal, frequent job changes without clear reasons can be a warning sign. It might mean anything or nothing so worth digging deeper.


Gaps in Employment: Unexplained gaps can be concerning. Always ask for context during the interview to understand the candidate’s situation. Often, it’s a perfectly reasonable explanation that can give you a better understanding of their personality. Just sometimes, it can also be a warning sign.


Overly Polished CV: If it looks too good to be true, it might be. Cross-check credentials and ask for specifics to ensure they’re not embellishing their experience. A bit of ‘wiggle room’ is tolerable but it’s wise to also be cautious.


Interview Insights


Vague Answers: If candidates struggle to provide concrete examples of their past achievements or responsibilities, it might indicate a lack of experience or embellishment.


Overly Negative: Beware of candidates who bad-mouth previous employers or colleagues. It could indicate poor interpersonal skills or a tendency to blame others.


Lack of Enthusiasm: If they seem disinterested or unenthusiastic about the role, it’s a red flag. Passion and motivation are key indicators of future performance.


Behavioural Cues


Punctuality: Arriving late without a good reason shows a lack of respect for your time and could indicate future reliability issues.


Communication Style: Pay attention to how they communicate. Will they be a good fit within the rest of the team dynamics? Good communication is crucial for teamwork and project success.


Body Language: Non-verbal cues can reveal a lot. Avoid candidates who seem defensive, overly nervous, or disinterested. Be mindful that some people may exhibit these same signs when they’re anxious about the interview situation. Be sure to help put them at ease as best you can to get the best out of them.


Background Check Basics


References: Don’t skip this step. Speaking with past employers can provide valuable insights into the candidate’s work ethic and behaviour.


Social Media: A quick glance at their public social media profiles can give you a sense of their personality and professionalism. If their vibe doesn’t fit with your current company policies, can it be taught?


Background Checks: Conduct thorough background checks to verify employment history, education, and any criminal records.


By being vigilant and recognizing these red flags early in the recruitment process, you can save yourself from potential headaches down the line. Trust your instincts, ask the right questions, and don’t be afraid to dig deeper. Remember, finding the right candidate is worth the extra effort. 


If you’d like an extra hand with the whole process, just get in touch!


Current Roles 

By Elliot Landy May 2, 2025
Earlier this year, Madeleine attended a LinkedIn event called ‘Future Ready’ that focused on AI and how it can drive business development in the recruitment industry. Poor Mads had been joking for ages that one day her job would be overtaken by ChatGPT, so it was good to see her looking relieved the next day! 😂 As much as we use AI regularly to speed up certain tasks and save time, the human element is still very much needed to get decent results. For Chat GPT (or any AI software) to be of any real use, the processes behind it need to be solid, consistent and applied properly. You wouldn’t hire an admin assistant without giving them some training and we think of AI in the same way. If you wanted to use it to write a job spec, for example, you’d need to use a prompt that specifies the correct tone of voice, then check the text for inaccuracies, dodgy spelling and any missing information. AI is never going to replace our team’s decision-making, intuition or judge of character, so they don’t need to worry about being replaced! But what it does do is improve productivity so we can spend more time interacting with people and doing what we’re good at. 
By Elliot Landy April 30, 2025
How many times have you felt like you’re surrounded by idiots? There might be a very good reason for this (unless they are certified idiots, then you’re screwed!). 🥴 At Harte, we frequently refer to Persona Profiling, which uses four colours (red, blue, yellow and green) to identify individual traits so we can develop a better understanding of ourselves and others. From a recruitment point of view, this helps to define a job seeker’s characteristics and assess whether they’d be suited to a role or fit in with a business’s culture. Someone who is a ‘fiery red’ for example, will be results-orientated, strong-willed, and driven to achieve, whereas a ‘cool blue’ personality will have a more conventional energy that thrives on analysis and asking questions before making a move. Knowing this sort of information makes finding the right ‘fit’ for a company a whole lot easier because we have a clear idea of the traits and behaviours that are aligned with the role. It also gives us an indication of when we need to take a step back and slow things down in interviews to really get to know the job-seeker properly. If you’re keen to find out more about the four personality types, have a read of (or listen to) this book: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Surrounded-Idiots-Behavior-Effectively-Communicate/dp/1250179947 Do you know what energy colour you lead by?
By Elliot Landy April 29, 2025
Basic salary: Up to £63,000, £5,100 car allowance, so total up to £68,100 per annum, plus a 5% annual discretionary bonus. Location: Leeds
More Roles