What Even is a Counter-Offer and Should You Take One?

You've handed in your resignation, ready to embark on a fresh new chapter in your career. But lo and behold, the next day your boss comes back with a counter-offer – more money or a promotion. It’s flattering, it’s intriguing, but is it the right move? Let’s dive into the dizzying world of counter-offers and see if they’re worth your while.

The Lowdown on Counter-Offers

A counter-offer is your employer's way of saying, "Please stay! We’ll sweeten the deal!" It’s a way to make you reconsider your resignation by presenting you with a shiny new proposition. However, be careful! Accepting this new deal means your old contract becomes null and void. In the UK, taking this new offer means your old agreement is history. 


PRO TIP [and general life hack]: Make sure to read the fine print before making any decisions.


The Sneaky Economics

Replacing you isn't just a matter of your salary. There are significant costs associated with rehiring, training, and the whole shebang. In today’s tech and digital realms, finding a star like you is rarer than a four-leaf clover. Without your skills, the company's progress slows, leading to financial headaches.


The Mind Games

You've made up your mind to leave, but now doubts are creeping in, making you feel topsy-turvy. This psychological roller-coaster is known as cognitive dissonance. A counter-offer can seem like a lifeline, but take a moment to think it over before making any hasty decisions.


Weighing the Pros and Cons

Before you start doing a jig over the counter-offer, let’s break down the pros and cons. Yes, it feels fantastic to be wanted, but a snap decision might harm your long-term goals.


Re-evaluate Your Reasons for Leaving

Reflect on why you wanted to leave in the first place. If it’s a gruelling commute or something equally distressing, extra money won’t magically make it disappear. Unless your boss is offering a teleportation device, be cautious.


Trust Issues

Accepting a counter-offer might make your employer question your loyalty. They might hesitate to invest in your development if they think you’re just in it for the money.


Office Politics

News of your decision to stay could spread like wildfire, causing colleagues to question your loyalty. This could turn the workplace into a drama-filled soap opera.


Follow the Money

If your company suddenly has the funds to give you a raise, why now? Be a bit sceptical of their motives and what’s driving this sudden generosity.


The Illusion of Promotions

A new job title might sound grand, but is it a genuine promotion or just a smokescreen? Don’t let yourself be fooled by shiny new titles.


Your Professional Reputation

Recruiters worked hard to get you that new job. If you back out now, it could leave a sour taste and harm your professional reputation with them in the future.


The Statistics

Consider this: about 50% of people who accept counter-offers leave within a year. Even top executives know that staying put after a counter-offer can damage careers.


Handling the Counter-Offer Maze


Ready to navigate this tricky situation? Here are some steps to help you make a wise decision:


Be Prepared

Most employers will try to persuade you to stay when you resign. Be ready for this conversation with a clear head. Don’t rush – ask for time to think it over.


Make a List

Be practical and jot down the pros and cons of each option. Sometimes what shines in one might be a con in the other.


Take Your Time

This decision could change your life. Take your time to think, ponder, and weigh every angle.


Talk to Your Boss

Have an honest conversation with your boss about your future at the company. See if the counter-offer really reflects your worth or if it’s just a temporary fix.


Mind-Blowing Stats

Don’t be surprised if accepting the offer raises questions about your loyalty. It’s just business, but it stings nonetheless.


Final Thoughts

When your employer makes a counter-offer, it can make you feel like the belle of the ball. But it can also stress you out. Working with a good recruitment agency can help guide you through these murky waters. If you’re flying solo, pause before grabbing that tempting offer. Does it really fix why you wanted to leave? Your decision to go marks a turning point – staying might block future promotions or job security.


In the end, if a shiny new job beckons, it’s often wiser to leap forward. Counter-offers rarely fix the root of the problem that made you look for a change.


Current Roles 

By Elliot Landy May 2, 2025
Earlier this year, Madeleine attended a LinkedIn event called ‘Future Ready’ that focused on AI and how it can drive business development in the recruitment industry. Poor Mads had been joking for ages that one day her job would be overtaken by ChatGPT, so it was good to see her looking relieved the next day! 😂 As much as we use AI regularly to speed up certain tasks and save time, the human element is still very much needed to get decent results. For Chat GPT (or any AI software) to be of any real use, the processes behind it need to be solid, consistent and applied properly. You wouldn’t hire an admin assistant without giving them some training and we think of AI in the same way. If you wanted to use it to write a job spec, for example, you’d need to use a prompt that specifies the correct tone of voice, then check the text for inaccuracies, dodgy spelling and any missing information. AI is never going to replace our team’s decision-making, intuition or judge of character, so they don’t need to worry about being replaced! But what it does do is improve productivity so we can spend more time interacting with people and doing what we’re good at. 
By Elliot Landy April 30, 2025
How many times have you felt like you’re surrounded by idiots? There might be a very good reason for this (unless they are certified idiots, then you’re screwed!). 🥴 At Harte, we frequently refer to Persona Profiling, which uses four colours (red, blue, yellow and green) to identify individual traits so we can develop a better understanding of ourselves and others. From a recruitment point of view, this helps to define a job seeker’s characteristics and assess whether they’d be suited to a role or fit in with a business’s culture. Someone who is a ‘fiery red’ for example, will be results-orientated, strong-willed, and driven to achieve, whereas a ‘cool blue’ personality will have a more conventional energy that thrives on analysis and asking questions before making a move. Knowing this sort of information makes finding the right ‘fit’ for a company a whole lot easier because we have a clear idea of the traits and behaviours that are aligned with the role. It also gives us an indication of when we need to take a step back and slow things down in interviews to really get to know the job-seeker properly. If you’re keen to find out more about the four personality types, have a read of (or listen to) this book: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Surrounded-Idiots-Behavior-Effectively-Communicate/dp/1250179947 Do you know what energy colour you lead by?
By Elliot Landy April 29, 2025
Basic salary: Up to £63,000, £5,100 car allowance, so total up to £68,100 per annum, plus a 5% annual discretionary bonus. Location: Leeds
More Roles